Scarpetta Beach

Gurney’s Resort

290 Old Montauk Highway

Montauk, New York

This is in a large resort, so you need to get through a few things to find the restaurant, so ask an employee for help.  (If you’re thirsty when you arrive, stop inside the door for some fruit-infused water.).  Once you arrive, request a table outside, overlooking the big beach, so you can get a preview of where you’ll be after dinner! Get spaghetti with olive oil. And if you want, there’s lots more.

After dinner, you can get desert from the menu or (my choice) from the coffee bar inside or go play on the beach.